Welcome to the Sunrise Drive, Greensborough:
PROTEST AGAINST THE PROPOSED WORSHIP HALL SITE

VCAT HEARING 11th JULY 2012

This site has been started so as to enable the dissemination of relevant information regarding the proposed development of the old milk-bar site on the corner of Sunrise Drive and Simon Crescent into a Brethren Worship Hall.

Below are some further pages and links that contain relevant information. Please advertise this site to your neighbours so that no one is left out of the information loop.

 

History table

DATE INFORMATION / COMMENTS
16-5-2012 Committee meeting (Open to all) held to discuss steps to be taken and strategy. The next meeting will be Tuesday 22-5-2012. If you wish to attend, email us
14-5-2012

Hearing notce received from VCAT setting the hearing date: 11 July 2012 @ 55 King street, Melbourne. (Hearing length is up to 3 days).
Internet site for vcat is www.vcat.vic.gov.au

9-5-2012 Today Tonight report - Battling the Brethren The 84th community to be affected. The Real Estate Religion
13-12-2011

WE ARE GOING TO VCAT

Yesterday, you should have received a letter (if you submitted an official protest to council) from "Planning & Property Partners" acting on behalf of the Pascoe Vale Trust (The Exclusive Brethren) indicating that they have lodged an application for review at VCAT for the proposed worship hall at Sunrise drive.
Each objector has 14 days from receipt of the letter to submit the supplied form to VCAT if you wish to contest the application.
I am upset that we only have 14 days to respond as this comes right on the Xmas period and may be already away.
If you are going away for XMAS before the committee has a chance to meet, then I suggest that you submit the form directly to VCAT rather than waiting on us.

11-11-2011 Nillumbik Council Alternate Motion 8-11-2011
People's victory against the Brethren A Current Affair: 9/11/2011
9-11-2011

Results from the council meeting held 8-11-2011: The Worship Hall proposal was rejected 4 votes to 3.
I would like to thank all members of our community who came to the meeting to show all that this issue is extremely important to us and worth fighting for as well as all the people who spoke on the issue. I would also like to thank the Nillumbik Councillors who supported us on the night. We cannot become complacent on this issue and must keep fighting the battle at each stage.
On behalf of the Sunrise Nillumbik Community Committee.

03-11-2011 Council Meeting Details (Click this link) If you have not received the "Address The Committee" form from the coucil, you can download the file here Click to download the form
A Current Affair story 2/11/2011 Canberra hosts cult conference
02-11-2011

IMPORTANT MEETING: Notice from Nillumbik council inviting all who put in a protest form to attend the planning meeting Tuesday 8th November where a decision will be made regarding the submitted proposal. Make sure you submit your response to indicate you will be attending. If you cannot attend, you can nominate someone to attend in your place.

WE NEED AS MANY PEOPLE TO COME TO THE COUNCIL MEETING.

28-10-2011 Banule & Nillumbik Weekly article
Protest numbers updated from 146 to 149. Keep spreading the word.

Update from Belinda Clarkson on the applicability of rates. Below are extracts from various emails as well as the reference to the Section 154 of the Local Government Act mentioned.

Hi Belinda The current rate status of the properties are: · The school at Ironbark and Pioneer Roads is non-rateable. · The residence at Ironbark and Pioneer Roads is currently rated. We have been advised that they now use this as part of the school. The status will be changed to non-rateable as part of the supplementary valuation in December. · The properties on Diamond Creek Road are rateable. When construction has been completed and Council has been advised that these sites have had a change of use to charitable purposes, the properties on Diamond Creek Road will assessed as non-rateable

Dear Belinda Further to your email, advice from officers follows: Further to your enquiry at the recent Blue Lake Ward meeting for Cr Clarkson, I am writing to confirm that under Section 154 (2)(c) of the Local Government Act 1989 (the Act), land used as a place of worship is not rateable as it is deemed to be held for charitable purposes under the Act. Land at 60-62 Sunrise Drive, Greensborough is currently rateable as it is deemed to be used for "mixed use". To be deemed non rateable under the Act, the owner/occupier is required to apply for a change in use which demonstrates that the land is now used for charitable purposes. Council records currently indicate that there are five premises used as a place of worship by the Brethren which are deemed non rateable. The Diamond Creek Road and Sunrise Drive premises are currently deemed rateable.

21-10-2011 Official protest numbers updated from 137 to 146. KEEP SENDING OBJECTIONS TO THE COUNCIL
20-10-2011 Diamond Valley Leader news article 19/10/2011 Diamond Creek Church vandalised
18-10-2011 I along with Sal, Leigh and Denis attended the Blue Lake Ward meeting 17/10/2011 and I thought I'd keep you informed of what was discussed relative to the worship hall(s).
Firstly, I want to thank Belinda Clarkson for the meeting and the opportunity for we the residents to put our questions forward with the hope of having them answered.

The meeting started at 7pm at the Yarrambat Golf Club rooms and was well attended by many Nillumbik residents. Unfortunately, I would have liked more of our local community there in order to field questions to Belinda and other council members. Many issues were raised, but I will only cover the questions we put to Belinda and others.

Q: Do the Brethren Worship halls pay rates?
A: The council CEO was quite confident they did not, but Belinda to check and get back to me with a definite answer.

Q: When will the issue be raised at a planning meeting?
A: The tentative date is the Tuesday 8th November. But we should get notification prior to this meeting.

Q: Will we get an opportunity at this meeting to discuss with council our issues?
A: No. This meeting is to allow us to put our objections forward. Each person attending the meeting will be given a maximum of 3 minutes to put their objections forward. There is no limit on how many people can attend and put objections forward. I URGE ALL WHO HAVE PUT WRITTEN OBJECTIONS FORWARD TO ATTEND THE MEETING. The committee will be formulating a presentation but don't rely on this alone. Show you care by preparing your own or joining us at the next committee meeting.

Follow up question to Belinda. If we wish to address the council in a round table discussion. how can this be arranged?

Issues I think we need to follow up before the council meeting.
1. A Title search for both the Sunrise Drive and Beales Road milk bar sites. Is this something council can help us with Belinda?
2. So far we have had responses from Harry Jenkins MP and Danielle Green MP. Hon. Matthew Guy (Planning minister) and Jenny Macklin MP are still to give any response. I will follow up with their offices.
- Contacted Ms. Macklin's office and spoke to Lochlan. I have booked a tentative meeting for the 10th November (earliest available time - to be confirmed by her office)
- Contacted Mr. Guy's office and spoke to Susan Turner. Susan will forward our concerns to Mr. Guy.
14-10-2011 Protest numbers updated
12-10-2011 Photo's from the Community Meeting 9th October 2011 in front of the milk bar 
View our community meeting on  Channel 9's 'A Current Affair' news story:  http://www.aca.ninemsn.com.au/article/8358684/battling-brethrenville
Document added: Brisbane City Vs The Exclusive Brethren (2008)
11-10-2011 IMPORTANT. WATCH CHANNEL 9 A CURRENT AFFAIR TONIGHT AS OUR COMMUNITY MEETING LAST SUNDAY WILL BE SHOWN ON AIR.
This site was temporarily blocked by teh provider while a content review was being undertaken. I assume that someone reported the site for abuse or inappropriate content.
Well, the site has passed their review and is now live again.
9-10-2011 IMPORTANT MEETING: THE SUNRISE DRIVE COMMUNITY MEETING SUNDAY 9th October at 2pm in front of milk bar site.
The meeting was well attended by local residents, our councillor, media and guest speaker. More detail to follow in the next few days.
6-10-2011

Sent group email to all members regarding the upcoming community meeting. It is important that YOU attend to keep well informed of what is happening with the proposal and objections. Some items on the agenda:

- Update on where we are regarding the proposal. Belinda Clarkson (Blue Lake Ward Councillor) will be at the meeting
- Special guest speaker
- Documentation available for viewing
- Fencing issues

Media will be present on the day.

Council informed me that the fence matter is being examined
10-2011

Letters prepared and being sent to our members of parliament detailing the issues we have with the proposal.
- Jenny Macklin MP Member for Jagajaga http://jennymacklin.net.au/
- Harry Jenkins MP Federal Member for Scullin http://www.harryjenkins.com/
- Danielle Green MP State Member for Yan Yean http://daniellegreen.org.au/

Submitted by email a query to the council about the legality of the fence erected on the proposed site.

4-10-2011 !!!!!!! Letter drop done detailing the next Sunrise Drive Community Meeting in front of the milk bar Sunday 9th October 2011 !!!!!!!
3-10-2011 2nd committee meeting held.
27/9/2011 NEW Links to Peebs.net added where postings have been made refering to our site and our situation
26/9/2011 News article in the Diamond Valley Leader 24th September 2011 - Fight to block Brethren in Greensborough moves online
22/9/2011

1st Sunrise Drive community meeting held. Minutes available

20/9/2011 Video story on Ch. 7 Today Tonight. Click here to see video
I've also submitted information about us to Today Tonight and A Current Affair via their web sites.
Email sent to our group indicating we have had media interest and what we should do next.
12/9/2011 Updated number of official protests to 137

9/9/2011

Contacted by Anna Whitelaw: Journalist with the Weekly (Fairfax media) who is interested in writing an article. Extract of her email is shown below.

Hi, I'm a journalist with the Weekly, and I'm writing a story about the proposal. I was hoping you could email me your contact details or call me this evening or tomorrow morning, with a few comments about the group of residents opposing this and why. email: awhitelaw@fairfax.com.au

6/9/2011 New Link: Pascoevale Gospel Trust v Nillumbik SC [2005] VCAT 2333 (3 November 2005)

Louise Williams responded to my email request regarding submitting the Objection Form.

An objection can either be emailed or posted to Council. If an objection is to be emailed, it must be emailed to nillumbik@nillumbik.vic.gov.au.
If an objection is to be posted, it must be posted to the following address:-

Planning Services
Nillumbik Shire Council
PO Box 476
Greensborough VIC 3088

4/9/2011 Sent email requesting  nominations for a committee to oversee this issue.
3/9/2011 Details of planning permits issued to date for land occupied by the Exclusive Brethren
1/9/2011 Diamond Valley Leader article

Contacted the Diamond Valley Leader (Dave Crossthwaite) by phone and email to introduce ourselves. (Email: diamondvalley@leadernewspapers.com.au)

Below is the response to my email to Belinda Clarkson regarding the meeting to be held Tuesday 6th September. I've forwarded this email to all members of the email group and have requested people to respond if they would like to attend. This way we can put forward a unified face.

Dear Ms Clarkson

I have been informed by a fellow resident of the Sunrise Estate that there is a meeting next Tuesday 6th September at the Aston Manor (Refer Below). I am interested in attending the meeting to voice our concern regarding the proposed redevelopment of the milk bar site. I have a few questions:

1. What time is the meeting? 6.45pm
2. Who can attend? Open to the public.
3. What is being discussed regarding the proposed redevelopment? You register with the Council and you can speak for 3 minutes about what concerns you, about this proposed development.
4. How much time do we (as a group) have to put forward our objections? You are allowed 3 mins per person. If you are part of a large group, work a strategy where each of you represent a particular issue of concern. If you just want to have your say (even if it is similar to someone else), I believe you should be able to speak, after all you pay the highest rates in the state of Victoria, you should be able to have your 3 mins worth.
5. Who is attending the meeting? All Councillors should be present and senior council officers. I believe it is worth ringing the other Councillors prior to the meeting, so they fully understand your objection. Let as many people know about the meeting as you can, so you have good representation and can cover all issues. I believe I have covered all your questions. My contact number is 0439 755 411.

31/8/2011

Photo's of our 1st community meeting.
Email received by a resident from councillor Belinda Clarkson informing that there will be a Council Policy and Services Meeting on Tuesday September 6th at the Aston Manor, Diamond Creek. Time to be advised. It was suggested that we make a presentation of of our objectives.

25/8/2011 Council documents made available on this site
24/8/2011 This site started and a generic email address generated.
22/8/2011

Our petition was submitted to council to Andrea deBoer (e: andrea.deboer@nillumbik.vic.gov.au).
Andrea informed us that we can drop off Objection Forms to the council up to the council meeting where the decision will be made. This meeting is expected to take place either in October or November 2011.
She also informed me that the person responsible at the Nillumbik council for handling this proposal is their town planner - Louise Williams (e: louise.williams@nillumbik.vic.gov.au)

21/8/2011 The local community meets to discuss the proposal put forward to council and what where the next steps to be taken. A petition was also started and signed detailing the reasons against building a worship hall the site being proposed.

 

This site is being hosted for free at www.000webhost.com

 

Free web hostingWeb hosting